Paul Otto Manz (1919—2009)
Esurientes implevit bonis
When I was half my age, literally, a twenty three year-old student, a guest recitalist visited the Lutheran Theological Seminary at Philadelphia. Being a chapel organist there (and not because I played poorly this virtuoso’s complexly notated works), I was recruited to be a driver for Dr. Paul O. Manz.
I recollect explicitly being frozen with fascination, in the presence of this dignitary, the dread of driving a legendary musician to his appointments. More than anything, I will never forget the dignity this gentleman showed to me, literally a poor seminarian. I know what it feels like to be judged unjustly or pre-judged. I felt not a scintilla of that from Dr. Manz. His faith lived out Martin Luther’s comment on this text from Luke; that we should “neither cling to the high and rich nor fly from the poor and lowly.” Too many people “judge according to outward appearance; therefore, they often err” (Luther’s Works, “The Magnificat” page 52).
I guess I did “cling,” so to speak, to Professor Manz—in admiration for what he taught us, his immense contribution to Lutheran spirituality and to the worship of the church catholic. A long-time favorite quote of mine comes from Manz’s take on our calling to pursue whatever things are excellent:
We reserve excellence for our God. Only the best will do.
Only that which lifts us to the cross,
the heart of God exposed, is good enough.”
A master of improvisation, Maestro Manz exercised creative fidelity—though grounded in traditional hymnody, he yet pushed the edges of composition and performance. I imagine hearing Manz to be akin to hearing, in his day, that master of contrapuntal invention, Johann Sebastian Bach (1685—1750).
In Latin, from the Luke’s Magnificat, a phrase I have come to love is this: Esurientes implevit bonis—“God has filled the hungry with good things.” In Bach’s setting, Mary’s lilting soprano dances with flutes: we hear hungering ones filled with good things, searching ones delighting in a surfeit of satisfaction, aching ones finally finding comfort. Today, we might say, grieving ones being filled with Christ’s grace to bear through their loss.
Prior to the death of Paul’s Ruth, his wife of 65 years, in the summer of 2008, my dear colleague, Joanne Negstad and I were received into the Manzes’ cozy apartment by Mary Bode, their daughter. We laughed at very old stories, talked about very good and bad music and learned many new things that enchanted Minnesota afternoon. But years before I came to Lutheran World Relief, long before I met Dr. Manz, he and Ruth became donors and supporters of LWR. They who filled ears and hearts with songs from God also contributed to fill with food people living in physical hunger throughout the world.
For these hands that provided beauty for our souls as well as bread for the poor, now thank we all our God!
(Follow this link to listen to a 2001 public radio interview with Manz)





